Why We're a Self-Pay Practice: The Benefits of Therapy Without Insurance
By Jeanne Cross, LCSW, LAC · Published

"Do you take insurance?" is one of the first questions we hear from people looking for a therapist. Our answer is no. Like most specialty providers, EMDR Center of Denver does not participate in any insurance plans.
That is a deliberate choice, and we made it with our clients in mind. When you pay for therapy directly, your care stays between you and your therapist. No third party decides what you work on, how long your sessions run, or what goes into a file about you. Here is what that means in practice, and how to tell whether self-pay is the right fit for you.
Your privacy stays in your hands
To pay a claim, an insurance company needs information about you. At a minimum that means a mental health diagnosis, and it can include treatment plans and details from your records when the insurer reviews your care. Once submitted, that information sits with a company you never chose to confide in. If you are covered under a spouse's or parent's plan, the policyholder may also receive statements showing that you saw a therapist.
When you pay directly, nothing is sent to an insurer. Your records stay with our practice, protected by the same confidentiality laws and ethical standards that cover all therapy. Federal privacy law backs this up: when you pay for a service in full yourself, you can ask your provider not to share it with your health plan, and the provider must agree.
For many of the people we work with, that privacy is the point. People healing from religious trauma, working through addiction, or holding a professional license, a security clearance, or a public-facing role often want their therapy to stay theirs. So do many healthcare workers and first responders, veterans, and high achievers. Self-pay makes that possible.
No diagnosis required to get help
Insurance pays only for treatment of a diagnosed condition that it considers medically necessary. To bill a plan, a therapist has to assign you a diagnosis, often after a single meeting.
Many people come to us with something real and painful that is not a disorder: grief after a loss, the death of a pet, the end of a marriage, burnout, perfectionism, chronic people pleasing, a block in performance, a hard chapter of life. Self-pay means you do not have to be labeled to be helped.
It also keeps a label from following you. Applications for life insurance, disability insurance, and some jobs ask about mental health history. We still assess carefully, and we will talk with you about a diagnosis whenever it is clinically useful. The difference is that it becomes a clinical conversation that stays between you and the therapist rather than a billing requirement.
Flexibility to work the way that fits you
Insurance plans are generally built around one format: a standard 50 minute session, about once a week. Insurers can limit how long a session runs, how many sessions they will cover, and which kinds of treatment they will pay for.
Self-pay removes those limits. We offer one-hour sessions, 90-minute sessions, and EMDR intensives of two hours or more. A one-hour session is a solid, effective way to do this work. Some people like a longer block, with more time to settle in, process, and close. Many of our clients choose intensives for that reason, or because fewer, longer appointments fit a busy life. Our intensives FAQ covers the details.
You and your therapist choose the format, and you can change it as you go. Come weekly, schedule an intensive around a demanding season, or take a break and return. None of it needs anyone's approval.
You choose your therapist, and the two of you set the course
Insurance networks narrow your options to whoever is on a list. Paying directly lets you choose a therapist for their training and for how well you fit together, which research has long linked to how well therapy works. If you want a clinician with advanced EMDR training and experience with anger, addiction, OCD, or grief, you can simply choose one. Because we work by telehealth, you can do that from anywhere in Colorado.
The same freedom applies once therapy begins. Insurers can ask a therapist to justify continued sessions, and they can decide that coverage should end. That can interrupt care at a hard moment. With self-pay, your goals set the pace, and therapy ends when you and your therapist agree the work is done.
Predictable costs and a faster start
Insurance is not always the cheaper path it appears to be. With a high deductible, you may pay full price for months before coverage begins, then copays after that, with the chance of a denied claim along the way.
With self-pay, you know the fee for every session before you book. There are no surprise bills and no claims to track. Federal law also gives self-pay clients the right to a Good Faith Estimate of expected costs. We accept credit cards as well as HSA and FSA cards, so you can pay with pre-tax health dollars. Current fees are on our Rates page.
You can also start sooner. There is no insurance authorization to wait for. Begin with a free 15-minute consultation and schedule from there.
Is self-pay right for you?
Self-pay usually costs more out of pocket than an in-network copay, and for many people using insurance is the right call. If cost is the deciding factor, an in-network therapist is a good option. Getting care matters more than where you get it.
Self-pay tends to be worth it when:
- Privacy matters to you, personally or professionally
- You want a specialist rather than whoever is in network
- You would like longer sessions or an intensive
- You do not want a diagnosis on your record
- You want to set the pace and length of therapy yourself
Want to read more first? Start with What is EMDR?, Is EMDR Right for Me?, and How to Find an EMDR Therapist in Colorado, or our posts on EMDR for anxiety and depression.
If that sounds like you, we would be glad to talk. Schedule a free 15-minute consultation or call us at 720-464-3444.
Frequently asked questions
Does EMDR Center of Denver take insurance?
No. EMDR Center of Denver does not participate in any insurance plans.
When does self-pay tend to be worth it?
Self-pay tends to be worth it when privacy matters to you, you want a specialist rather than whoever is in network, you would like longer sessions or an intensive, or you want to set the pace and length of therapy yourself.
Which session formats does EMDR Center of Denver offer?
We offer one-hour sessions, 90-minute sessions, and EMDR intensives of two hours or more.
Where can I find current fees?
Current fees are on our Rates page. With self-pay, you know the fee for every session before you book.
Is the first consultation free?
Yes. Begin with a free 15-minute consultation and schedule from there.
Education and Crisis Disclaimer
This article is general information about how therapy payment works. It is for education and is not legal advice, medical advice, a substitute for therapy, or emergency care. If you are in crisis or thinking about suicide, call or text 988 (Suicide & Crisis Lifeline), call 911, or go to your nearest emergency room. EMDR Center of Denver does not provide emergency services.
Sources
- U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Under HIPAA, may an individual request that a covered entity restrict how it uses or discloses that individual's protected health information? (linked in the article)
- Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Good faith estimate and patient-provider dispute resolution process for uninsured or self-pay individuals (linked in the article)
- EMDR Center of Denver. Rates (linked in the article)
